Retreat House NY
Enter your access code to view this confidential property report.
This report is confidential and prepared exclusively for the recipient.
Enter your access code to view this confidential property report.
This report is confidential and prepared exclusively for the recipient.
The most comprehensive property performance analysis available
Scroll to see more · 112 total photos available on Airbnb
Retreat House NY · 3557 State Route 209, Wurtsboro, NY 12790
Top Strategy: Entire Estate STR · Luxury Group Bookings
Key Highlights
Property Profile
A one-of-a-kind 6,000+ sq ft renovated farmhouse estate on over 90 acres of private Hudson Valley countryside. Listed on Airbnb as "Estate w/Indoor Pool, Gym, Arcade & Nature Trails" — currently rated ★ 5.0 across 16 reviews, designated a Guest Favorite, and operating under Superhost status. Managed by RetreatHouse NY LLC. Top 10% of homes on Airbnb based on ratings, reviews, and reliability.
Property Details
| Address | 3557 State Route 209, Wurtsboro, NY 12790 |
| Configuration | Single-family renovated farmhouse estate |
| Bedrooms / Baths | 6 BR / 5.5 BA · 14 beds · 16+ guests |
| Rental Sq Footage | ~6,000 sq ft (of 7,000 total) |
| Acreage | 90+ acres · Private Hudson Valley countryside |
| Guest Capacity | 16+ guests |
| STR Status | Active · Superhost · Guest Favorite · Top 10% |
| Airbnb Listing | "Estate w/Indoor Pool, Gym, Arcade & Nature Trails" ↗ |
| Owner | RetreatHouse NY LLC |
| Website | www.retreathouseny.com ↗ |
Signature Amenities
Beyond the indoor pool and game room, three experiences set this property apart from every competitor in the Catskills market.
Showing 24 of 112 photos · View all on Airbnb ↗
Catskills STR Market
The Catskills / Sullivan County STR market is one of the strongest weekend-getaway markets in the Northeast, driven by NYC proximity (90 min), year-round demand, and a severe shortage of large-group luxury inventory. Retreat House NY sits at the premium end of this market.
Projected Monthly Gross Revenue
Annual Total: $143,500 · Peak Aug $25,300
Occupancy: Market vs. Managed
| Month | SO Managed | Market Avg | Premium |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | 15% | 22% | –7% |
| Feb | 40% | 28% | +12% |
| Mar | 44% | 32% | +12% |
| Apr | 50% | 38% | +12% |
| May | 58% | 44% | +14% |
| Jun | 35% | 52% | –17% |
| Jul | 75% | 62% | +13% |
| Aug ★ | 89% | 68% | +21% |
| Sep | 55% | 55% | 0% |
| Oct | 58% | 52% | +6% |
| Nov | 24% | 35% | –11% |
| Dec | 12% | 30% | –18% |
| Annual | 46% avg | 43% avg | +3% avg |
Demand Drivers
Sullivan County and the broader Catskills region benefit from multiple overlapping demand drivers that sustain year-round bookings at premium rates — particularly for large-group, amenity-rich properties like Retreat House NY.
The #1 weekend escape market for 8+ million NYC metro residents. Demand spikes every Friday–Sunday, 52 weeks a year. Only ~5% of Sullivan County listings accommodate 16+ guests — Retreat House NY captures the entire large-group segment.
NY/NJ hosts 8 World Cup games at MetLife Stadium (June 11–July 19, 2026). 1.2 million visitors expected with a $3.3B regional economic impact. The Catskills is positioned as the premier overflow accommodation hub — 90 min from MetLife. Rates should command 2–3x normal during this window.
An indoor inground pool is one of the rarest and most searched amenities in the Catskills market. It eliminates the seasonal drop-off that affects outdoor-pool properties and commands a $150–$300/night premium year-round.
Corporate retreats, family reunions, bachelorette parties, and milestone celebrations are the fastest-growing STR booking segment. Retreat House NY's 16+ guest capacity, game room, and event spaces are purpose-built for this market. Bethel Woods (Woodstock site) is 15 min away.
Interactive barnyard animals, 90+ acres, marked nature trails, brook, meadow, and seasonal stream create a 'resort without the resort fees' experience. Drives viral social sharing, repeat bookings, and 5-star reviews — the property's ★ 5.0 rating across 16 reviews confirms it.
Holiday Mountain Ski Resort is just 18 miles away. Combined with the indoor pool, Retreat House NY can capture ski weekend bookings in Dec–Feb — the current soft season (10–13% occupancy). Targeted ski-weekend and New Year's Eve packages could add $15,000–$25,000 in winter revenue.
Comparable Properties
The following are active Airbnb listings in the Catskills / Sullivan County market comparable to Retreat House NY in size, amenities, and guest capacity. All data sourced from AirDNA and live Airbnb listings.
📅 Data as of March 2026 · Sourced from AirDNA & live Airbnb listings · Updated monthly
| Property | Location | BR/BA | ADR | Occupancy | Est. Annual Gross | Key Differentiator |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ultimate Luxury Escape w/Indoor Pool & Sauna ⭐4.79 | Jeffersonville, NY | 4BR/3BA · 14 guests | $650–$850/night | ~52% | ~$120,000 | Indoor pool, sauna, movie theater — no barnyard, no trails, 2 fewer BR |
| Sleeps 19! Indoor Pool & Sauna · Guest Favorite ⭐4.82 | Narrowsburg, NY | 6BR/3BA · 16+ guests | $700–$900/night | ~55% | ~$140,000 | Indoor heated pool, sauna — only 3 baths vs 5.5, no barnyard, no 90-acre estate |
| Serene Estate: Heated Pool, Tennis, Sauna, Hot Tub | Catskill Mountains, NY | 6BR/4BA | $800–$1,000/night | ~50% | ~$150,000 | More established listing, further from NYC (1h45m) |
| Retreat House NY ★ 5.0 · Guest Favorite | Wurtsboro, NY | 6BR/5.5BA · 16+ guests | $1,570 avg · $2,530 peak | 88.9% peak (verified) | ~$105K verified · $185K optimized | Indoor pool · Barnyard · 90 acres · Game room · Fitness · Trails · 90 min NYC |
Competitive Advantage
Retreat House NY is the only property in the Sullivan County market combining an indoor inground pool, interactive barnyard animals, a full game room, fitness room, and 90+ acres of private nature trails under one roof. This amenity stack is unmatched in the local market and justifies ADR at the top of the comp range — particularly for the large-group and corporate retreat segments.
Revenue Projections
Projections anchored to verified Airbnb data ($1,570 ADR, $2,530 peak, 88.9% peak occupancy). Comparable active Catskills 6BR+ listings cross-referenced via AirDNA, Rabbu, and PriceLabs. All net figures reflect a 30% management and operating expense ratio.
Based on verified Airbnb performance data ($1,570 ADR, 88.9% peak occupancy). Owner-operated, standard pricing, no optimization protocol.
Strategic pricing, multi-platform listing, professional photography. Partial implementation of optimization blueprint.
Full optimization: corporate retreats, seasonal events, direct bookings. Stays Optimized full-service management protocol.
Revenue Scenario Comparison
The difference between self-managed and professionally managed STR on this Catskills retreat is +$56,000/year in net revenue — that's the management gap. Corporate retreat bookings, seasonal event pricing, direct booking channels, and full-season optimization are the drivers.
LTR Baseline — 3-Source Weighted Average
The long-term rental figure of $3,150/mo ($37,800/yr gross · $26,500/yr net) is a weighted average of three independent sources: Zillow $3,500/mo (50%), Redfin $2,900/mo (30%), Rentometer $2,800/mo (20%) — all March 2026.
5-Year STR Premium vs. LTR
At the moderate scenario ($101,500/yr net), compared to a $26,500/yr LTR net baseline, the 5-year STR premium exceeds $375,000 in additional owner income.
Current vs. Optimized Gap
The gap between current verified performance (~$105K gross) and a professionally optimized operation. Achievable through strategic pricing, multi-platform distribution, and professional management.
ℹ Projections anchored to verified Airbnb performance data: $1,570 ADR average, $2,530 peak ADR, 88.9% peak occupancy, ~$105K implied annual gross. Conservative scenario reflects current verified pace. Moderate and peak scenarios derived from active Catskills 6BR+ comps. LTR baseline of $3,150/mo ($26,500/yr net) is a 3-source weighted average. Net figures assume a 30% combined management and operating expense ratio. Actual results vary.
Optimization Strategy
Retreat House NY is already a strong performer. Our role is to close the gap between current results and the property's true revenue ceiling through professional management, dynamic pricing, and targeted marketing to the highest-value guest segments.
Real-time pricing adjustments based on live market data. Peak weekend rates pushed to $900–$1,800/night during foliage, holidays, and summer. FIFA 2026 window should command 2–3x normal rates.
Synchronized listings across Airbnb, VRBO, Booking.com, and direct booking channels. Unified calendar management prevents double-bookings and maximizes fill rate across all platforms.
Targeted outreach to corporate event planners, wellness retreat organizers, and large-group booking platforms. The fitness room, home office suite, and 90-acre private estate make Retreat House NY ideal for Mon–Thu corporate bookings.
Dec/Jan occupancy of 10–13% is the single largest revenue gap. Strategy: Holiday Mountain ski weekend packages (18 miles away), New Year's Eve premium pricing, January wellness retreat packages. Target: 35–45% winter occupancy.
SEO-optimized listing copy targeting 'large group Catskills', 'indoor pool NY', and 'corporate retreat Hudson Valley'. The existing ★ 5.0 Guest Favorite + Superhost status (16 reviews · Top 10%) is protected and leveraged as a ranking signal.
Custom pricing and promotions for Catskills foliage season, NYE, Memorial Day, Labor Day, and local events. Early-bird discounts for multi-week bookings during shoulder season to smooth revenue curves.
Property Tour Video
A complete walkthrough of the estate — indoor pool house, game room, barnyard, nature trails, and every amenity that makes Retreat House NY one of the most distinctive large-group properties in the Catskills.
Property Location & Grounds
3557 State Route 209, Wurtsboro, NY 12790 · Sullivan County Catskills · 90 min from NYC
Book Your Stay
Book directly through our website — same rates as Airbnb, with real-time availability synced across all platforms. Select your dates below to check open nights and complete your reservation.
Availability synced in real-time with Airbnb · Secure booking powered by Hospitable · Questions? support@propertyiq.report
Proof of Concept
Our Charlotte property at 2124 Tyvola Rd demonstrates exactly what professional management delivers. In 7 months of operation, we have outperformed market projections across every metric.
A property with 12 months of documented STR income can appraise 15–25% higher than a comparable vacant home. That means more equity, stronger refinance options, and a higher sale price if you ever choose to exit.
Documented STR income raises appraised value vs. a vacant or LTR property.
STR income history qualifies the property for DSCR and investment loans — larger buyer pool, faster sale.
A cash-flowing asset with a track record sells faster and at a premium vs. a property with no income history.
Normally, rental losses are "passive" and can only offset other passive income — not your W-2 salary. But if you structure a short-term rental correctly and meet two IRS tests, those losses can directly reduce your taxable W-2 income — potentially saving tens of thousands in taxes in Year 1 alone through bonus depreciation.
Prepared by Stays Optimized LLC · April 2026 · For educational purposes only — consult a qualified CPA or tax attorney before implementing any strategy.
To escape passive loss rules, the average guest stay across all bookings must be 7 days or fewer. If this test is met, the property is treated as a business activity and losses can offset W-2 income.
You must also materially participate. The IRS provides 7 tests — meeting just ONE qualifies you. Most practical: participate more than 100 hours/year AND more than any other individual.
If you personally use the property for more than 14 days OR more than 10% of the days it is rented, IRS Section 280A reclassifies it as a personal residence — eliminating most deductions.
A cost segregation study reclassifies property components, then bonus depreciation lets you deduct a large portion all in Year 1.
A more powerful designation that removes all passive loss limits. Requires: 750+ hours/year in real property trades AND more time in real estate than any other profession.
This report documents your projected STR income, ADR, occupancy, and annual revenue — the exact figures your CPA needs to model bonus depreciation.Educational purposes only. Does not constitute tax or legal advice. Consult a CPA or tax attorney before implementing any strategy.
Why PropertyIQ
We are not a listing service. We are a full-service STR management company that treats your property like a business — because it is one.
Daily pricing adjustments, comp monitoring, and seasonal strategy. We leave no money on the table.
Hotel-standard cleaning protocols between every stay. Linen service, restocking, and quality inspections.
We handle every guest message, issue, and review response. You are never on call.
Vetted local vendors for all repairs and maintenance. Issues resolved before they become reviews.
Transparent monthly statements and direct deposits. You see exactly what came in and what went out.
Monthly reports with occupancy, ADR, revenue, and market benchmarks. Full visibility, zero surprises.
Ready to Maximize Retreat House NY
Retreat House NY is already a ★ 5.0 Guest Favorite with a verified ADR of $1,570/night and 88.9% peak occupancy. With professional revenue management, multi-platform distribution, and corporate retreat marketing, we project $101,500–$129,500 net per year — a $28,000–$56,000 annual increase over current verified performance.
PropertyIQ · Property Performance Analysis · support@propertyiq.report · 845.749.7126
Schedule a free 30-minute strategy call with the PropertyIQ team. We'll walk through this report, answer your questions, and outline the exact steps to maximize this property's revenue.
Book a Strategy Call — propertyiq.reportFree · 30 minutes · No obligation
© 2026 Stays Optimized LLC · PropertyIQ Report · Confidential · For RetreatHouse NY LLC · Updated April 2026
